Commons:Deletion requests/Files in Category:Murals in the City of Manchester

Files in Category:Murals in the City of Manchester

There is no freedom of panorama for 2D art in the United Kingdom.

• File:At Manchester 2018 052.jpg
• File:Deansgate, City of Manchester, May 2020 (03).jpg
• File:Graffiti in the streets of Manchester 1.jpg
• File:Graffiti in the streets of Manchester.jpg
• File:Legion mural - geograph.org.uk - 732037.jpg
• File:Lucy Bronze by Toria Jaymes.jpg
• File:Mural at the Museum of Science and Industry - geograph.org.uk - 985787.jpg
• File:Mural on Elliot House, Charlestown - panoramio.jpg
• File:Mural on the Hippodrome.jpg
• File:Mural on the site of Bilsborrow Primary School (now demolished) in Moss Side, Manchester - panoramio.jpg
• File:Nevercrew inhuman barriers Manchester.jpg
• File:No Fear Here - Manchester Street Art (34265987623).jpg
• File:Public art, Stevenson Square - geograph.org.uk - 1082260.jpg

Adeletron 3030 (talk) 14:33, 18 November 2022 (UTC)

• For File:At Manchester 2018 052.jpg - it's an image of a car park, with the mural and building in the background, so de minimis should cover that. For some of the others, I think Commons:Copyright_rules_by_subject_matter#Graffiti applies. Thanks. Mike Peel (talk) 16:03, 18 November 2022 (UTC)
• The File:Lucy Bronze by Toria Jaymes.jpg appears to have a note about a Flikr author appears to be on the "bad author list". I think that is the most likely upload to be deleted. Iggy the Swan (talk) 16:42, 18 November 2022 (UTC)

Bad author list for other types of work, irrelevant. Kingsif (talk) 07:24, 19 November 2022 (UTC)

•  Keep File:Legion mural - geograph.org.uk - 732037.jpg and File:Nevercrew inhuman barriers Manchester.jpg - The first image I've cropped as those 4x4s were rare in the UK, Second image I'll photoshop the artwork out as we only have one file of Category:Hilton House, City of Manchester,

For the rest the artwork is way too prominent so DEMINIMIS wouldn't apply unfortunately, cropping would imho generally render the image useless as there's not enough car park to warrant the images. (You could technically crop File:Mural at the Museum of Science and Industry - geograph.org.uk - 985787.jpg but none of the cars are rare and it's small/low quality Geograph image so imho would be a waste of time)–Davey2010^Talk 22:57, 18 November 2022 (UTC)

• Copying over my comment from where I was made aware of this: I think there is debate on where murals fall as 2D works of art — I think it was something about if the art is intended as part of the building decorations then it is actually part of the building and covered by FoP, but I'm not sure.
  That is to say, I have seen photos of murals kept before due to an argument I interpreted as that, I don't know if it is something referenced in guidelines or not. Kingsif (talk) 07:24, 19 November 2022 (UTC)